Section 38 Fitness Reports NZ: The CP(MIP) Act 2003 Explained
Section 38 of the Criminal Procedure (Mentally Impaired Persons) Act 2003 is how a New Zealand court obtains a health assessor's report while a defendant is in custody — for fitness to stand trial, insanity, or a sentencing matter. This reference explains when the court can order one, who can be directed to prepare it, and how the fitness inquiry that follows works.
This is a factual reference published by Precision AOD Solutions Ltd, a New Zealand provider of AOD assessments and forensic risk reports for sentencing and parole. Precision AOD Solutions does not undertake Section 38 fitness assessments — where a fitness question arises the court directs the assessor, and counsel can still instruct us for the sentencing or parole reports that follow.
Quick Answer
What is a section 38 fitness report in New Zealand?
A section 38 report is an assessment prepared by a health assessor — a registered psychiatrist, psychologist or specialist assessor — ordered by a criminal court under s 38 of the Criminal Procedure (Mentally Impaired Persons) Act 2003 while the person is in custody. It assists the court to determine fitness to stand trial, insanity within the meaning of s 23 of the Crimes Act 1961, or sentencing-related questions. The court directs the assessor; counsel does not commission it.
What a Section 38 Report Is
Where a New Zealand criminal court needs independent health evidence about a defendant in custody — fitness to stand trial, insanity at the time of the offending, or a sentencing question — the statutory instrument is the assessment report ordered under s 38 of the CP(MIP) Act 2003: the section 38 report, or S38 report. It is prepared for the court, by an assessor the court names — a court-directed document, not something either party privately commissions.
When the Court Directs an Assessment
Section 38 applies whenever the person is in custody at any stage of the proceeding — before or during the hearing or trial, while awaiting sentence, or while an appeal is pending. The prosecution or the defence can apply, or the court can act on its own initiative. There is no statutory doubt threshold in s 38 itself: the power is discretionary, and in practice courts direct an assessment when fitness or insanity is in issue, or when the sentence under contemplation turns on the person's condition.
When a person is in custody at any stage of a proceeding against the person, whether before or during the hearing or trial, or while awaiting sentence or the determination of an appeal, a court may, on the application of the prosecution or the defence or on its own initiative, order that a health assessor prepare an assessment report on the person for the purpose of assisting the court to determine 1 or more of the following matters: (a) whether the person is unfit to stand trial: (b) whether the person is insane within the meaning of section 23 of the Crimes Act 1961: (c) the type and length of sentence that might be imposed on the person: (d) the nature of a requirement that the court may impose on the person as part of, or as a condition of, a sentence or order.
Subsection (5) gives the power effect despite other enactments, but for a defendant under 20 it is subject to ss 171–175 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 and to s 15 of the Bail Act 2000.
Who Can Be Directed to Report
The report must be prepared by a health assessor, a term the Act defines in s 4:
health assessor means— (a) a practising psychiatrist who is registered as a medical practitioner; or (b) a psychologist; or (c) a specialist assessor under the Intellectual Disability (Compulsory Care and Rehabilitation) Act 2003
Psychologist means a health practitioner registered with the Psychologists Board under the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003; the third limb lets the court direct a specialist assessor appointed under the Intellectual Disability (Compulsory Care and Rehabilitation) Act 2003 where the fitness question turns on an intellectual disability. Under s 38(2) the court may make attendance at an approved place a condition of bail, or order detention in a prison — or, where prison would be inappropriate and a health assessor has certified that a hospital or secure-facility assessment is desirable, in a hospital or secure facility — for up to 14 days. Section 38(3) forbids detention where the person is bailable as of right or would have been released but for the report; s 38(4) requires the court to record its reasons for hospital or secure-facility detention; and s 40 caps total detention at 30 days, extendable only with the person's or their guardian's consent.
Section 39 adds two controls: the court may direct a second opinion from another health assessor at any time while the matter remains to be determined, and every s 38 order is deemed (unless the court otherwise directs) to require the assessor to consult, wherever practicable, with the person's caregiver, any welfare guardian and — for a child or young person — each parent or guardian and the family or whānau.
The Fitness Inquiry Timeline
A section 38 report informs the fitness question — it does not decide it. Once the report is before the court, the Act runs the process through a fixed sequence (the scheme below reflects the Act as amended in 2018):
| Stage | What happens | Statutory basis |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Report ordered | The court orders a health assessor to prepare an assessment report while the person is in custody; a bail condition or up to 14 days' detention can accompany it. | CP(MIP) Act 2003, s 38 |
| 2. Fitness determined | The court must receive the evidence of 2 health assessors as to whether the defendant is mentally impaired. If impairment is established, each party is heard, and the court finds whether the defendant is unfit to stand trial — on the balance of probabilities. | s 8A |
| 3. Involvement inquiry | If the defendant is unfit, the court inquires whether the evidence establishes, on the balance of probabilities, that the defendant caused the act or omission forming the basis of the offence — before trial (s 10), in a Judge-alone trial (s 11) or in a jury trial (s 12). | ss 10–12, reached via s 8A(5) |
| 4. Outcome | If the court is not satisfied the defendant caused the act or omission, the charge is dismissed under s 147 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 and the unfitness finding is deemed quashed. If satisfied, the defendant is dealt with under subpart 3. | s 13 |
| 5. Disposal inquiries | Before any subpart 3 order, the court orders inquiries into the most suitable method of dealing with the person — completed within 30 days. The person is bailed to an approved place or remanded to a hospital or secure facility; public protection is paramount. | s 23 |
| 6. Disposal orders | Detention as a special patient under the Mental Health (Compulsory Assessment and Treatment) Act 1992 or as a special care recipient under the Intellectual Disability (Compulsory Care and Rehabilitation) Act 2003 — or, where detention is not necessary, treatment as a patient, care as a care recipient, no order, or immediate release. Undertakings to undergo treatment can be taken into account. | ss 24–25 |
Two features matter most: the two-assessor rule — the court cannot determine fitness without the evidence of two health assessors on the mental impairment question, and any finding must be recorded — and the clock. Disposal inquiries must be completed within 30 days of the s 23 order, and a special-patient order requires evidence from at least one health assessor who is a psychiatrist (s 24).
What the Report Must Address
The report addresses whichever of the s 38(1) purposes the court has directed it for. Where the purpose is fitness, the report speaks to the Act's definition of unfit to stand trial — a definition worth quoting in full, because it is the checklist the court will measure the report against:
unfit to stand trial, in relation to a defendant,— (a) means a defendant who is unable, due to mental impairment, to conduct a defence or to instruct counsel to do so; and (b) includes a defendant who, due to mental impairment, is unable— (i) to plead: (ii) to adequately understand the nature or purpose or possible consequences of the proceedings: (iii) to communicate adequately with counsel for the purposes of conducting a defence
Each limb generates its own evidence base: pleading and understanding the nature, purpose and possible consequences of the proceedings go to courtroom participation; communicating adequately with counsel goes to instruction. Under s 8A the clinical question is framed as mental impairment, and the two health assessors' evidence is directed to exactly that; the deemed consultation direction in s 39 shapes the report's background material. Where the report is ordered for sentencing purposes — sentence type and length, or the nature of a sentence requirement — it addresses the person's condition against those questions instead; where the purpose is the insanity question, it addresses the Crimes Act test below.
Insanity at Trial vs Insanity at the Time of Offending
Two legally distinct questions are often collapsed into the word insanity — and the Act keeps them apart. Fitness to stand trial concerns the defendant's state now, at trial: can they conduct a defence or instruct counsel to do so? Insanity at the time of the offending concerns the defendant's state when the act was done or omitted, and it is governed by s 23 of the Crimes Act 1961:
No person shall be convicted of an offence by reason of an act done or omitted by him or her when labouring under natural imbecility or disease of the mind to such an extent as to render him or her incapable— (a) of understanding the nature and quality of the act or omission; or (b) of knowing that the act or omission was morally wrong, having regard to the commonly accepted standards of right and wrong.
Where the court is satisfied the defendant caused the act or omission but was insane at the time, the defendant is dealt with under the Act's act proven but not criminally responsible on account of insanity pathway — a definition inserted with effect from 13 December 2022 by the Rights for Victims of Insane Offenders Act 2021. Section 38 is the common entry point for both questions: the same power that orders a fitness report can order one for the s 23 question, and the disposal provisions (ss 23–25) apply where a person is found unfit to stand trial or found insane alike. Because the two questions are dealt with separately, counsel should be precise about which one a report is ordered for.
How NZ Differs from the UK and NSW Schemes
Most English-language commentary on fitness to stand trial comes from the United Kingdom or Australia, and the terminology does not travel cleanly. New Zealand's scheme has its own architecture:
| Feature | New Zealand | England and Wales | New South Wales |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governing statute | Criminal Procedure (Mentally Impaired Persons) Act 2003 | Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964 | Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Procedure Act 2020 |
| Term used | unfit to stand trial | unfit to plead | unfit to be tried |
| Who assesses | Health assessor: psychiatrist, psychologist or specialist assessor (s 4); two required (s 8A) | Registered medical practitioners directed by the court | Qualified mental-health practitioners under the 2020 Act |
Three differences do the most work in practice. New Zealand hard-codes the assessor classes — psychologists and intellectual-disability specialist assessors included, not only doctors; states the standard of proof on the face of the Act (balance of probabilities, s 8A(3)); and runs the involvement question as a separate statutory inquiry (ss 10–13) rather than resolving it alongside the fitness hearing. Assessment detention is tightly capped too: 14 days per order, 30 in total even with consent. Counsel importing UK or NSW commentary should re-anchor every proposition to the CP(MIP) Act's own text.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a section 38 fitness report in New Zealand?
A section 38 report is an assessment prepared by a health assessor — a registered psychiatrist, psychologist or specialist assessor — ordered by a criminal court under s 38 of the CP(MIP) Act 2003 while the person is in custody, to assist the court on fitness to stand trial, insanity under s 23 of the Crimes Act 1961, or sentencing-related questions. The court directs the assessor; counsel does not commission the report.
Who can be a health assessor under the CP(MIP) Act 2003?
Section 4 defines a health assessor as (a) a practising psychiatrist registered as a medical practitioner, (b) a psychologist registered with the Psychologists Board, or (c) a specialist assessor under the Intellectual Disability (Compulsory Care and Rehabilitation) Act 2003. The court names the assessor and may direct a second opinion under s 39.
Who receives a copy of a section 38 report?
Under s 45, the Registrar must give a copy of the report to the subject (the person assessed) and to the subject's counsel. The court may order parts withheld from the subject where disclosure would be likely to prejudice the subject's health or endanger safety, but the entire report must be shown to counsel, and the subject or counsel may give evidence on matters in the report.
What is the difference between unfit to stand trial and insanity in NZ law?
Unfitness concerns the defendant's ability to take part in the trial: due to mental impairment, they are unable to conduct a defence or instruct counsel. Insanity under s 23 of the Crimes Act 1961 concerns the defendant's state at the time of the offending — whether disease of the mind prevented them from understanding the nature and quality of the act or knowing it was morally wrong. A s 38 report can assist with both, but the Act runs them as separate processes.
Is a section 38 report the same as a fitness-to-plead assessment in the UK or NSW?
No. England and Wales determine fitness to plead under the Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964 using Pritchard-derived criteria, and NSW consolidates its scheme in the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Procedure Act 2020. New Zealand's CP(MIP) Act 2003 uses the term unfit to stand trial, requires two health assessors, adds a separate involvement inquiry, and caps assessment detention at 14 days.
Does Precision AOD Solutions prepare section 38 reports?
No. Precision AOD Solutions does not undertake Section 38 fitness assessments — where a fitness question arises, the court directs the assessor. Counsel can still instruct us for the sentencing or parole reports that follow.
Where the Sentencing and Parole Reports Fit
Precision AOD Solutions does not undertake Section 38 fitness assessments — where a fitness question arises, the court directs the assessor it names. Where the same client proceeds to sentence, counsel can still instruct us for the reports that follow: independent pre-sentence AOD assessments, psychological and violence risk assessments, Section 27 cultural reports and reports for parole hearings.
For how the report types relate, see the court reports reference, the statutory reference matrix, the pre-sentence reports explained guide and the Section 21 parole assessments guide — or contact us with the questions your report must answer.
